If you want love, you deserve to find it.

A dating experiment for Columbus singles who are tired of swiping. Tell us who you really are. We'll find people who fit your values, your life and your type. You read who they are first, then see who they are.

Serious relationships only · 100 founding members · Free

Applications are reviewed and members are selected by hand.

To the single people: we see you.

Dating hasn't failed you. The way we date has.

Scrolling past engagement photos. Wedding after wedding. Couples everywhere you look, and wondering when it's your turn. Tired of the swiping, the small talk that goes nowhere, the games.

A lot of people have quietly given up hope of finding their person. We take that seriously, because we've felt it too. No one deserves to be alone, and if you want love, you deserve a real shot at it.

So we're giving dating the redesign it deserves, and bringing the hope back.

How it works

No scrolling through thousands of profiles. We do the work up front, and you live your life.

1

Tell us everything

Your faith, goals, lifestyle, dealbreakers and your type, as honest as you want. The more you share, the better we match you.

2

We do the work

We only reach out when someone truly fits. No match is better than the wrong match, so we'll never send one just to keep you busy.

3

Read, see, meet

Read why you match, then see their photos. If you both say yes, you get each other's number and set up the date.

Every match comes with a reason

No app tells you why it matched you with someone. We do. You'll know what you have in common before you ever say hi, including one honest difference, because nobody's perfect.

Attraction matters, and we match on it too. You teach us your type when you sign up. We just don't lead with it.

Example match

Why we matched you with J., 29, Clintonville

  • Faith is central for both of you, and you both want to raise kids in it
  • You're both savers who want to build something of your own
  • Small groups and game nights over big parties
  • A perfect Saturday: outdoors, then cooking for friends
  • They fit the type you described

One difference: you travel every chance you get, and J. prefers a couple of trips a year.

Now see J.'s photos

How we're different from dating apps

Dating appsPlus One Columbus
Swipe through thousands of profilesA few people who fit your values and your type
A swiping algorithm built to keep you hookedBuilt to get you off the app, with your person
Judge someone in half a second from a photoRead who they are first, then see their photos
You do all the workWe do the work up front. You relax.
Pay to see who likes youFree to start
Games, ghosting, dead-end chatsVerified people who want something serious

Millions watch couples fall in love before they ever see each other on TV, and only a handful get cast. We think everyone deserves that chance. No cameras, no casting call.

Human-led. AI-assisted. Always safe.

Applications are reviewed and members are selected by hand. AI helps sort the answers, but a person reviews every single match before it goes out. If it doesn't make sense, it doesn't get sent.

Every person verified

  • A real social profile, used only to verify you
  • Two selfies holding hand signs we assign
  • A confirmed phone number

Your info stays private

  • Answers and photos are never public
  • Matches see first name, readout and photos only
  • Deleted anytime you ask

Serious only

  • Everyone is looking for a committed relationship
  • Code of conduct: respect, honesty, public first dates
  • One report and you're out

A real person in your corner

You're not a number on a spreadsheet. You're someone we're rooting for.

On most apps, you pay a subscription and nobody ever talks to you. We're doing the opposite. Our team is here to support you through your whole dating journey. Right now that starts with me, Nathan, and as we grow, you'll always be able to reach a real person.

Wondering why you haven't been matched yet? We'll tell you honestly: we haven't found your right person yet, and we're not going to send you the wrong one. Nervous before a first date? Not sure how to read a match? Ask us. Think of it like talking to a friend who's in your corner. We're not therapists, but we care how this goes for you.

Every message gets a reply from a real person within 24 to 48 hours. We're all busy 😊

Why we're starting small

We believe dating can be revolutionized, but we don't want to build something big that doesn't work. Columbus is America's test market, where brands try new ideas first. We're doing the same with dating: 100 people, one city, a lot of care.

If it works, we'll bring it to more cities. If it doesn't, we'll be honest about that too.

Why join the first 100

  • Free until you find your plus-one. If we launch, founding members keep free access for their whole dating journey.
  • Not selected this round? You still get it. Every applicant gets free access if the app goes live.
  • Try something actually different. If you feel stuck, this could be what finally works.
  • Help shape the future of dating. Your feedback decides what this becomes.

Hey Columbus,
I'm Nathan.

I'm 30, single, a Christian, and Columbus born and raised. I went to Ohio State, I work in finance, and you'll find me in a workout class, dancing, traveling, or teaching myself music and coding.

I've been on plenty of dates. Some were great, but things didn't work out because of differences in values we only found out about later, or because someone moved away. Things that could have been known on day one.

That's why I'm building this: so the important stuff is out in the open from the start, nobody has to play games, and you don't spend months on someone you could have known wasn't the right fit. I'd love for you to be part of it.

Nathan Spain, founder of Plus One Columbus, smiling outdoors under a tree

Questions

Who can apply?

Columbus singles, men and women, ages 25 to 38, looking for a serious relationship. We plan to open it up to more people in the future.

Is it really free?

Yes. This first round is completely free, and founding members stay free until they find their plus-one.

What if I'm not selected?

You'll still get free access if the app goes live, and we'll keep you in mind for future rounds.

What if I don't get a match?

You stay in the pool for the next round. We only send a match when someone truly fits.

What if I'm not attracted to them?

You teach us your type when you sign up, and we only match you with people who fit it. You see their photos before you say yes.

What happens after we both say yes?

You get each other's first names and phone numbers, plus a suggested public spot for a first date. From there, it's all you.

Know someone who's single?

The best matchmakers have always been friends.

Your coworker who's tired of the apps. Your sister who deserves someone great. Your best friend who's given up hope. Send this their way. You might be the reason they find their person.

Share @plusonecolumbus

"Thought of you! It's a new dating experiment in Columbus where you read who someone is before you see them. Serious relationships only, and it's free: instagram.com/plusonecolumbus"

Ready to change the future of dating and find your Plus One? 💚